A video clip has been doing the rounds on the Internet recently about a “Tai Chi master” called Lei Gong who accepted the challenge of a Chinese MMA fighter/coach called Xu Xiaodong to an actual fight. Here’s what happened:
As you can see the Tai Chi master had his bell rung very quickly and very convincingly. The whole video lasts 47 seconds. It’s clear from the first few seconds of the actual fight that Lei Gong is way out of his depth and shouldn’t be in there with Xu. He had no idea how to deal with an opponent who was actually attacking him, not just dancing around making strange shapes in the air, like his student presumably do for him.
(The stoppage by the ref was a bit late for me, and Lei Gong ended up taking more punishment than he should have. The effects of head trauma are all too real, but it seems that this is the price he had to pay to be woken from his dream of magic fighting ability).
Generally, I think that this fight was a good thing for Tai Chi as a whole. Let me explain.
The challenge arose after Lei Gong appeared on a Chinese Television programme called “Experiencing Real Kung Fu” claiming to have sparring and fighting ability with Tai Chi. He spared one of the hosts of the show in the programme. See below at 9.30:
Xu’s beef with the show was that people claiming these sorts of abilities better be able to back it up.
The sad truth is that most things in China are fake, including their TV shows! I’ve seen so many of these types of shows now where Tai Chi masters go up against Muay Thai or Karate people, or wrestlers. They’re all fake. Does that mean Tai Chi is fake too? I don’t think so, but I think it exposes the complete lack of realism that is prevalent in the Tai Chi culture. It’s not rocket science: if you want to be able to actually fight with any art, then you have to practice actually fighting with it.
Xu seems to have a particular problem with the big dogs of Chen village who charge a lot of money for people to become disciples to learn their special skills. I can see where he’s coming from – if you look at what you learn in a typical seminar from a big name in the Chen style, then none of this is going to prepare you for an encounter like the one Lei Gong was in.
Xu’s argument, which I think is logically valid, is that if you’re going to charge all that money for something you better be able to prove it works. He’s now challenged the son of Wang Xi’an, one of the “4 tigers of Chen village”, but Wang’s son will only send his student, who has also been trained in SanDa (Chinese kickboxing with throws as well) to fight Xu. Xu, understandably says this will not do, because he wants to test Chen style Tai Chi. This will probably rumble on a bit and lead nowhere.
I was chatting with a friend about the whole thing and he said something like “I think that all martial arts, once they actually spar end up looking like some version of MMA”.
I think he’s probably right. I’ve written before about the delusion of grace under pressure and how so many people’s idea of what Tai Chi should look like in a fight is so way off.
MMA is what martial arts look like when stripped down to pure functionality. When all the cultural trappings have been removed. Chinese Martial Arts does contain its own bad-ass martial artists, but still, those arts contain things that are not purely about fighting. And for a good reason – they perform a useful social function. MMA also performs a useful social function, but more in the same way that Western boxing does, not in the way that Chinese Martial Art does.
Perhaps we’re all missing something. There are special skills you can only get from Tai Chi, and I think people have a right to teach these things without having to fight MMA to prove it works. I also don’t believe that all the people who are paying lots of money to become indoor disciples of Chen style masters think they are being given a kind of ‘master-key’ to martial arts that will mean they will be able to fight 21-year old athletes without ever having to spar first. It’s more like they are buying into a tradition. Once they buy in they’ll (hopefully) get the skills the tradition is famous for*, and be able to set themselves up as teachers. The problem comes when they get delusional and start to see themselves as bad-ass fighters when they don’t have a right to. This situation is made worse by the acceptance of fakeness, or cheating, in Chinese culture and TV shows.
It’s a messy situation, but it is what it is. Welcome to the world of Tai Chi. What matters is you and your training. Use your own reasoning to asses what you’re doing and what skills it is actually giving you, and don’t start to claim you can do things you can’t, otherwise you might suffer a painful wake-up call, like Lei Gong did.
*Of course, whether somebody who is not Chinese and not even from Chen village would ever really be taught the real skills of the family is open for debate anyway.
8 thoughts on “Full contact Tai Chi. A painful lesson in reality.”
Pingback: Take a long hard look at yourself, Chinese martial artist | The Tai Chi Notebook
Pingback: Xu Xiaodong is back in high thrills Bird Box challenge | The Tai Chi Notebook
Here’s a clip of him doing his form – I think it speaks for itself: https://www.facebook.com/tinsiki/videos/673236902861223/?hc_ref=NEWSFEED
Well, we wasted time talking about this, after all. The “Tai Chi” guy has spurious credentials and is a bit of a fraud: http://www.scmp.com/week-asia/opinion/article/2093104/opinion-why-kick-teeth-good-chinese-kung-fu?utm_source&utm_medium&utm_campaign=SCMPSocialNewsfeed
Pingback: Aikido vs MMA – real sparring | The Tai Chi Notebook
I do Tia chi. I have learned a few things from a boxer though. Especially moving around and small delicate hand blocks for defecting punches which is suprisingly effective and very “soft and tia chi like”. More effective against fast punches with a log reach.
Well, judging by the Chinese TV doc I posted to above, I wouldn’t say Lei Gong was up to much! (He does the trick of not letting a bird take off from his hand, which apparently is easy if you trim their feathers….)
Without having some idea of Lei Gong’s Taiji and fighting ability, it’s hard to accept that this bout says much about Taijiquan. From my perspective a lot of the Chinese martial-arts were seriously degraded when the communists forbade any CMA training and punished/killed a number of famous teachers. At present I think that CMA’s haven’t totally recovered, but there’s more that goes on in China, fight-wise, then we get to see as outsiders.
There are some fairly serious challenge matches that are kept hidden from public view (in all styles). Because of that, I don’t pay much attention to these one-off bouts