A look at the Cloud Hands movement of Tai Chi, and what it’s really all about
Cloud hands, or ‘wave hands like clouds’ as it’s also known, is one of those classic Tai Chi movements that characterise the art. It’s done in slightly different ways in different Tai Chi styles. Take a look at the variations:
Master Yang Jun, (Yang Cheng Fu, Yang style):
Master Chen Zhen Lei, (Chen style):
Master Sun Ping, (Sun style):
I’m not comparing myself to the masters above, but here’s a GIF of me doing it, since I have that on video I might was well add it to this post:
Me: (Old yang, also called Gu style)
As you can see, the Yang style is more of a vertical arm block, the Chen style is more of a horizontal elbow strike while the Sun style has the palms facing outwards. It’s a case of different horses for different courses, but while there are subtle differences between them, they all involve the common theme of stepping to the side while rotating the arms in circular motions (presumably like clouds on a windy day).
Martially speaking, I think of this movement as intercepting an opponent’s strike and throwing the attacker out, or applying a lock to their arm through the action of turning your waist. To the attacker it should feel like they’re putting their hand into a blender – it gets caught up and crushed and it shouldn’t feel easy to retract your arm once it’s trapped.
It’s easy for beginners to make the arms ‘flat’ in this posture – instead they need to be continually projecting outwards. I think of them as being like the antlers of a stag, or the branches of a tree – they grow outwards, and are slightly curved. If you’re going to intercept your opponents strike with this technique, then it’s going to help ‘catch’ their attack if the intent in your arms (your antlers) is to project outwards.
The real lesson of Cloud hands though is to turn the waist. It’s a common mistake to not turn the waist enough in Tai Chi, and I find that, for the beginning student, a breakthrough in this area often only comes about through a study of Cloud Hands as an isolated technique, repeated over and over. Notice that if you removed the stepping from Cloud Hands then it wouldn’t be a million miles away from the stationary silk-reeling exercises that go along with Tai Chi, with one hand performing a clockwise circle and the other an anticlockwise circle. Indeed, performing Cloud Hands repeatedly can serve a similar function to basic Silk Reeling exercises.
As it says in the Tai Chi classics, the body should be directed by the waist at all times, so as you turn from side to side in Cloud Hands (let’s not worry about the stepping for now) your arms should only be moving because your waist is moving. If your waist stops, then your arms should stop too. This especially applies at the crossover points, when you’ve turned all the way to the side and the arms swap position, so that the lower one becomes the upper one, and vice versa. This is the point that beginners usually drop the principle and use some isolated arm movement, instead of keeping it all coming from the waist. It’s usually a revelation to the student here that you need to turn the waist a little more than you think you do to keep it as the commander of the movement – you should feel this using muscles in your lower back you normally don’t reach.
Remember, in Tai Chi you’re looking to continually maintain a connection (a slight pull) from the toes to the fingers, with movement directed by the dantien like the spider at the centre of a web. If you keep this connection (or slight tension) and the waist control at these crucial crossover points in Cloud Hands then you’ll be well on your way to keeping it throughout your whole form performance.
12 thoughts on “Wave hands like clouds”
Pingback: Jinyiwei - Chapter 20 - SassyStrawberry Translates
Pingback: Dab Paint Like Clouds – Steve's Narrow Gauge Adventure
In tai chi what exactly energy is derived and where the energy come from our body
Thanks JK – glad you’re enjoying the blog!
*… by “left step” I meant right foot steps left, together with the left foot and arms extend to the left! 😂
Hi, came to look at your blog through Ken’s podcast. Great episode btw and I like your stuff. I found this article from your “big reads”.
My teacher of classical Yang style emphasises that when you move from your hips, your knees should not be compromised from the range of motion. As you can see from the masters, their legs are solid and straight as they twist from their core. They don’t twist their knees or break their rooting.
Also I’m taught to breathe out when stepping out to the direction of the exercise, as in when walking to the left, breath out on the left step. It’s much harder to explain than to do. 😀
Keep on practicing folks. Greets from Finland!
Hi Kim, you breathe in on one turn to the side and breathe out on one whole turn back. The in and out breath are interchangeable in this posture so you can start with either.
What is the breath work with wave hands like clouds. Is it inhale to one side and exhale to the other? Or inhale when you switch hands, and exhale as you are moving across your body? Thank you!!
Pingback: Happy New Year! Here are my most popular Tai Chi Notebook posts from 2018 | The Tai Chi Notebook
Thanks for the 3 videos showing the different styles. I am looking for the health benefits of Cloud Hands and found this. I already practice one form of Tai Chi Ruler and 3 other Qigong styles. Thanks again Peter.
Thank you. How did you find this post incidentally? It’s quite an old one.
A very simple and good explanation of the need for waist rotation