Here I want to discuss what a natural posture means in Tai Chi Chuan. I was working on the posture we call ‘Fist under elbow’ with a student today. The posture looks like this:
The word translated as ‘fist’ could also mean ‘punch’, so you could equally call the posture, ‘Punch under elbow’. It looks a bit like the Judo Chop I talked about recently, but it’s not done like that at all in application. Instead of a chopping, downward, movement it’s a forward and outwards, palm strike done with the left hand. You can see this immediately when you see it done in motion. Here’s Yang Jun, the grandson of Yang Cheng-Fu who is pictured above, teaching the movement in his family’s style of Tai Chi.
You might ask why your other hand is punching under the elbow. I was always taught this was a hidden technique, where you’d turn the left hand into a deflection of the opponent’s attack and punch them with your right, but in the Tai Chi form it wasn’t show explicitly, and the punch was hidden away under the elbow… In application, it looked a lot like a little bit of Wing Chun Kung Fu.
I always have doubts about the validity of these sorts of explanations though. Firstly, I don’t know why you’d want to hide a technique like this? Who are you hiding it from, and why? And it’s not an especially deadly technique, so it’s not like it is dangerous for people to see it. There are much more dangerous techniques shown openly in the form. And secondly, if you don’t actually practice it then you’ll never actually be able to do it under pressure, so hiding things away is not an ideal practice method.
I think it’s much more likely that the posture itself has special cultural significance (as say, part of a religious ritual, or maybe it relates to Chinese cosmology), so was included in the Tai Chi form sequence, or perhaps it’s something of a signature move that was handed down over the generations from an older martial art, and has lost its original meaning, but remained as a kind of nod of respect to the forefathers.
Either way, it’s in the Tai Chi form now, and shows no sign of being removed, so we might as well get on with learning it properly.
My point in writing this article was that I find students generally don’t perform this posture particularly well. Perhaps it’s something to do with the arm position being slightly uncomfortable unless you can relax sufficiently, but it seems particularly suited to making mistakes. Maybe it’s because it looks a bit like an “on guard!” posture, but if you ask a student to take up this posture they will invariably hunch the shoulders, or make their leading arm too stiff and aggressive, or get the angle of the hand and fingers all wrong.
Here’s an example of what I mean. Look at how tense this guy’s arms are:
He’s holding up his right elbow instead of letting it drop. His left arm is almost locked straight and both arms are too high: Instead of ‘sinking the chi’ he’s letting it rise up, which makes him unsteady.
In Tai Chi the shoulders should naturally round and the elbows should drop – this makes your posture softer and more relaxed – ‘sung‘, as we say in Tai Chi.
If I was to walk up to the person above practicing on the beach and at the moment they formed their Fist Under Elbow I was to slap their arm away at the elbow then the chances are that I’d severely compromise their structure and balance, possibly knocking them over, giving me ample room to attack.
In comparison, if you look at the picture of Yang Cheng-Fu above again, then you can see he is much more relaxed and comfortable in his stance. You get the feeling that if you tried to slap his arm away he’d be able to just let his arm go with your motion, and let it swing back around and slap you in the face! (This was exactly what happened to me the first time I got hands-on with my Tai Chi teacher, so I can talk from experience!)
Yang Cheng-Fu’s more natural posture means that his centre of gravity is within himself in the area of the dantien. And because mind and body are linked, it’s more likely that his mind is focussed and aware of what’s happening. Once your physical centre of gravity starts to shift out of your base, so too does your mental focus. And equally, if your mind is all over the place when you’re doing your Tai Chi form then, more than likely, your physical balance will suffer for it.
In an ‘internal’ martial art we try to harmonise what’s happening between the external and the internal parts of the body. That’s what I’m trying to do in each posture of the Tai Chi form – become more centred,both mentally and physically. I want to have a more natural body that is free from artificial posturing. Postures that look ‘held up’, as if from invisible wires from the ceiling, are not as useful for combat as natural, rooted, aware postures that can meet the demands of the moment.
(A quick tip for getting a more natural posture is to take up a posture from the Tai Chi form, put your arms in what you think is the correct position, then take a big breath in, all the way up to your shoulders then let it all out in one big gasp. Let your arms settle to where they need to be, rather than holding them up. That relaxed, sunk, posture you now have is what you should be looking for in Tai Chi Chuan.)
As it says in the Tai Chi Classics:
4 thoughts on “Fist Under Elbow, and natural posture”
I don’t think it is punching under the elbow,
it is fiste under the elbow!
In his tutorial to the 42 combined Taichi quan form, Professor Li Deyin gave a nice application to Zhǒu dǐ chuí.
min 49:55 to 50:10
I’ve seen a couple of applications in the Chen style, but they all focus on a great, downward Closing of the body. The name is basically the same in Chinese: “zhou di kan quan”, which comes right after “two hands push mountain”. Yang Lu Chan was an illiterate country lad with a reportedly heavy accent and when he was naming the postures to Wu Yu Xiang, Wu misunderstood the “two hand push mountain” and entered something about “carry tiger to mountain”, which gives the Chen people hysterics when they hear it.
Mike – There’s definitely something missing in the Yang explanation of this posture. It would therefore be interesting to find out what this move is like in Chen style and find a video showing that application. Is it still called “Fist under elbow” in Chen style?
Yang Cheng Fu was the grandson of Yang Lu Chan. Yang Lu Chan studied and taught the Chen-style taijiquan (with some modifications; his teacher from Chen Village requested that he not teach the full art). The Yang-style taijiquan form is very obviously based on the choreography of the Chen-stylle Lao Jia Yilu, so really, in order to understand most of the postures in the Yang-style, you would have to go back to see what those postures were and how they were performed in the Chen-style. In the Chen-style Taijiquan, Fist under Elbow is a pure Closing movement. Taijiquan cycles endlessly from Open to Close to Open, etc. The current Yang-style explanation of a posture taken from the old Chen-style is sort of meaningless, in terms of Taijiquan theory. YMMV